Close Icon
Gear IconImportant Update:The City Guide web experience will be sunsetting on April 28, 2025. Please visit our FAQ to learn more.
Read more
Reloading results...

Suggestions for American Restaurant near Key West

Filters:
    • 8.7
      American$$$$View Menu
      806 Caroline St (btwn Williams & Margaret St), Key West
      Save
      • Stephanie E.

        Stephanie E. • February 28, 2016The BLT is simply on point! And the freshly squeezed orange juice is a delight.

    • 8.5
      American$$$$View Menu
      530 Simonton St (Southard St), Key West
      Save
      • Lee W.

        Lee W. • April 9, 2011Must get the almond crusted cinnamon French toast.

    • 8.4
      American$$$$View Menu
      600 Fleming St, Key West
      Save
      • Linnie D.

        Linnie D. • July 21, 2014Come here for a special celebration. We went for our anniversary and the table was decorated beautifully. The summer menu is now $26 for two courses but still a bargain. Amazing wine list.

    • 8.4
      American$$$$View Menu
      700 Front St, Key West
      Save
      • Val D.

        Val D. • April 12, 2010Get the fantastic Shrimp Salad, great service.

    • 8.3
      American$$$$
      220 Margaret Street, Key West
      Save
      • Rob-nChristopher R.

        Rob-nChristopher R. • March 8, 2015Conch Fritters, Prime Rib is phenomenal, Florida Lobster Tail, 1/2 price ANY draft and small plates for happy hour

    • 8.3
      American$$$$View Menu
      310 Duval St (at Caroline St), Key West
      Save
      • Lauren A.

        Lauren A. • September 2, 2012Blackened chicken pasta is spicy but good! Dolphin sandwich is also tasty.

    • 8.8
      American$$$$View Menu
      2814 N Roosevelt Blvd, Key West
      Save
      • Bruno C.

        Bruno C. • September 1, 2015Great burgers and fries with a fair trade culture. Much love!

    • 8.2
      American$$$$View Menu
      1405 Duval St, Key West
      Save
      • Jennifer H.

        Jennifer H. • April 29, 2013The Wild Grouper is awesome! A bit pricey but makes it worthwhile sitting by the ocean.

    • 8.2
      American$$$$View Menu
      900 Southard Street (at Margaret St), Key West
      Save
      • Beverly S.

        Beverly S. • January 2, 2012Pasta and desserts from scratch. Delicious! Authentic key line pie, possibly the best I've tasted (and I'm a key lime pie connoisseur)

    • 8.6
      American$$$$View Menu
      801 Caroline St (at William St), Key West
      Save
      • Cassandra T.

        Cassandra T. • December 1, 2014Best fish sandwich and conch fritters in town

    • 8.5
      American$$$$View Menu
      202 William St, Key West
      Save
      • Shawn T.

        Shawn T. • December 2, 2012Solid happy hour, even better that they have an early one....early as in 7am-noon! Can't beat that!

    • 8.1
      American$$$$View Menu
      1000 Atlantic Blvd, Key West
      Save
      • Angelica F.

        Angelica F. • July 9, 2014Delicious calamari sauteed in marinara and Key Lime Pie! Service needs to improve!

    • 8.5
      American$$$$View Menu
      400 Front St, Key West
      Save
      • Rose A.

        Rose A. • July 26, 2010Great band. Nice vibe from tourist and locals. Can't wait to go back.

    • 8.4
      American$$$$View Menu
      2710 N Roosevelt Blvd, Key West
      Save
      • Ghaida✨

        Ghaida✨ • May 17, 2023Strawberry fried pancake was awesome!

    • 8.4
      American$$$$View Menu
      2814 N Roosevelt Blvd, Key West
      Save
      • M Gavin D.

        M Gavin D. • April 27, 2016Awesome food, exceedingly affordable, and speedy quick service!

    • 8.4
      American$$$$View Menu
      631 Greene St (at Elizabeth St.), Key West
      Save
      • Elizabeth B.

        Elizabeth B. • August 23, 2012Stuffed mushrooms and coconut shrimp were amazing!!!

    • 8.3
      American$$$$View Menu
      227 Duval St (at Caroline St), Key West
      Save
      • Mark H.

        Mark H. • August 22, 2015Street side seats along Duval to people watch and grab some great food and drinks! Plenty of frozen drinks too!

    • 7.9
      American$$$$View Menu
      700 Front St (at Margaret St), Key West
      Save
      • Noelle

        Noelle • June 25, 2014Try the oyster sampler if you can't decide, they are all delicious! Conch fritters are great too.

    • 8.2
      American$$$$View Menu
      512 Front St, Key West
      Save
      • Michael M.

        Michael M. • May 5, 2012The breakfast here is great. Good service and everything. The biscuits and gravy are top notch!

    • 7.9
      American$$$$View Menu
      313 Duval St, Key West
      Save
      • Tim M.

        Tim M. • March 7, 2011The wait staff was amazing. always on top of the drinks. try the california burger... its a bit messy but so good. loved the Nachos.

    • 7.9
      American$$$$View Menu
      308 Front St, Key West
      Save
      • Naomi T.

        Naomi T. • June 9, 2012The crab cake, from someone who eats a lot of crab cakes, was spectacular. All delicious chunks of crab, held together with wisps of delicious crunch.

    • 7.7
      American$$$$
      500 Duval St, Key West
      Save
      • Lindsay S.

        Lindsay S. • July 8, 2012The ribs were amazing!!!! Guava BBQ sauce was yummy!

    • 7.7
      American$$$$View Menu
      501 Southard St (at Duval St.), Key West
      Save
      • Ben G.

        Ben G. • August 14, 2010Cheesesteak with onions, mushrooms, and whiz is great!

    • 7.4
      American$$$$
      903 Duval St, Key West
      Save
      • Scot S.

        Scot S. • June 8, 20214 people in group, every menu choice was the best. Entertainment was very good. Staff was fun and professional

    • 7.6
      American$$$$View Menu
      3230 N Roosevelt Blvd, Key West
      Save
      • Samuel F.

        Samuel F. • July 6, 2017The restaurant is perfect. There are a waiter very good. CJay. Thank you for your care.

    • 9.0
      American$$$$View Menu
      Sunset Key, Key West
      Save
      • Sarp E.

        Sarp E. • January 5, 2016Highly recommend it for during your visit in KW. Great for breakfast and I am sure for sunsets. Even in a windy/cold day it's a good spot to enjoy.

    • 7.4
      American$$$$View Menu
      505 Front St (btwn Duval & Simonton St), Key West
      Save
      • Isaac C.

        Isaac C. • May 12, 2015The staff is awesome.. Breakfast was great, Mango Margarita Perfect!

    • 7.2
      American$$$$View Menu
      231 Margaret St, Key West
      Save
      • Meggan F.

        Meggan F. • August 29, 2014Oysters! Yum! Been coming here since I was a kid.... It's changed a lot since then but still brings back great memories. Cold beer and hand shucked oysters can't go wrong.

    • 7.1
      American$$$$View Menu
      115 Duval St (Front St.), Key West
      Save
      • Brittanie Q.

        Brittanie Q. • August 17, 2011Friendly staff! Great menu! The best part is they serve breakfast until 4pm!

    • 6.9
      American$$$$
      1114 Duval St, Key West
      Save
      • Krista M.

        Krista M. • August 3, 2017Great bar! Really enjoyed it and Max was a great bartender! Local vodka infused horse radish made an amazing Bloody Mary.

    • Don't see the place you're looking for? Add a new place to Foursquare.